Over the last few years or so, there has been two different types of "wins" being claimed by certain clans. Lets not mention names and keep this as unbiased as possible.
1. The first group believe that to win a runescape clan fight, you must be the last clan on that world, forcing the other clan to log out, no matter how you do it, through strength, numbers, crashers, outlasting or boredom.
2. The second group believe that to win you should punish the other clan enough to make them break rules such as bounds (going below gap/single) or gear (making the other clan rag/1 item) for example and once these rules have been broken, enough is enough and you have "won." Even if it means the second clan breaking these rules can then go and take an ending, and claim a win of their own based on the logic in part 1.
So my question is, what do you define as a clan fight win? Part 1 or Part 2? Obviously I realize that the clan having the most fun are the true winners, but from a strictly clan discussion point of view, what do you think?
1. The first group believe that to win a runescape clan fight, you must be the last clan on that world, forcing the other clan to log out, no matter how you do it, through strength, numbers, crashers, outlasting or boredom.
2. The second group believe that to win you should punish the other clan enough to make them break rules such as bounds (going below gap/single) or gear (making the other clan rag/1 item) for example and once these rules have been broken, enough is enough and you have "won." Even if it means the second clan breaking these rules can then go and take an ending, and claim a win of their own based on the logic in part 1.
So my question is, what do you define as a clan fight win? Part 1 or Part 2? Obviously I realize that the clan having the most fun are the true winners, but from a strictly clan discussion point of view, what do you think?